Best aggregators and market access for new P&C agents

Redditors say direct appointments are "difficult (not impossible) to get on your own" without a track record (source). These options publish low-barrier entry.

NameTypeFees / requirementsAppointments / ownershipSources
First ConnectaggregatorZero onboarding fees, zero subscription feesnot published[1]
Firefly AgencyaggregatorUpfront fee plus monthly fee (cost of comparative rater + management system); 90% commission split on all new business and renewalsDirect appointments with 12+ carriers[1] [2]
Horizon Agency Systemsaggregator$1,000 startup; $269/user/month standard ($259 for 2-5 users), $299/user/month advanced; no brokerage fee; 85% commission from policy one with fixed option to grow to 100%Dedicated, Shared and Broker Assisted Access programs; per-carrier administration[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
Smart ChoicenetworkNo joining, monthly, maintenance or exit fees; 70/30 split on program business, 100% after 'Leadership Level' capAgency keeps 100% ownership of book, renewals, expirations[1] [2]
Big "I" Alliance Blue (formerly Big I Markets)market access programFree: no initial, monthly or termination fees; no production minimums (Big I membership required)Agent owns expirations; sub-producer agreement[1] [2]
Agents Alliance Servicesaggregatornot publishedAgency owns 100% of agency, book, brand[1]
Pathpointdigital wholesalernot publishedSign up online[1]
Coterie InsuranceMGAnot publishedSign up online[1]
Neptune FloodMGAnot publishedSign up online[1]
The plain-English take: Start with one aggregator for admitted carriers (First Connect, Firefly, Horizon or Smart Choice; the trade-off is fees versus commission split). Add a free market access program like Big I Alliance Blue if you join your state Big I. Add an online-signup wholesaler for E&S risks. Redditors give the same advice: get market access first, then go after direct appointments once you have production.

Get the weekly Agent Network Guide

Weekly notes on agent networks, aggregators, wholesalers and MGAs: fees, contract terms and market access changes.

Or subscribe here →


Facts are taken from the cited sources and can change. Always read the actual contract.